A Classic Book That's a Tough Sell for Modern Kids

summarizeEditor's Summary

I'm torn about this classic book featuring stories by Arkady Gaidar - it's a beautiful hardcover with warm and cozy illustrations, but the sales team wrote on the cover with a permanent marker. The design is calm and kid-friendly, but I'm not sure if it's worth the 350 rubles. I'm still trying to figure out how to get rid of the permanent marker stain, but for me, that's what matters most - the book needs to captivate my child. The book includes several stories that are great for kids, and they're all classics. I've been using it for a while now, and the build quality is nice, but it's not without its flaws. The price is reasonable, especially considering the quality of the book, but the permanent marker stain is a major downside. I'm still deciding whether it's a good value for money, but I think it's worth considering if your child enjoys classic literature.

settingsSpecifications

Kararİyi

Kalite8/10

Ilişki7/10

HikayeKalitesi9/10

Hello everyone!

I often find new books at Fix Price, but I'm not always familiar with modern authors. I tend to stick with classic children's literature. That's why I was drawn to this beautiful book featuring stories by Arkady Gaidar.

Price: 350 rubles

The hardcover is nice, with warm and cozy illustrations by a real artist. The design is calm, kid-friendly, and beautiful. For me, that's what matters most - the book needs to captivate my child.

But there's one major downside - the Fix Price sales team wrote on the cover with a permanent marker. I haven't been able to remove it with regular cleaning products yet, so I'm still trying to figure out how to get rid of the permanent marker.

The book includes several stories: Chuk and Gek, The Blue Cup, Smoke in the Woods, Marusya, The Journey, Conscience, The Hot Stone. We haven't read them all yet.

The first story, Chuk and Gek, is a great place to start. It's a warm and relatable tale about two brothers waiting for their dad and getting into all sorts of silly and exciting situations. The story's about family, love, and anticipation.

Gaidar does a great job of describing the winter taiga, which is far from our usual experience. We've seen winter, of course, but when it gets cold, we usually stay indoors. So, the real atmosphere of the taiga is unfamiliar to us. However, the author does a great job of conveying the mood of the surrounding world, and it's a great opportunity to discuss with your child how people used to communicate without smartphones and the internet - by meeting in person and traveling differently than we do today.

I like that Gaidar's moral lessons are clear without being too preachy or overly simplistic. The stories are full of words we don't use in everyday conversation with kids - chapaevtsy, pioneer, collective farm, and loads more.

What does happiness mean? Everyone's got their own take on it. But the one thing everyone agrees on is that you've got to live honestly, work hard, and love and take care of this amazing planet.

Of course, there are some tough words to explain to a kid. Like, who's a geologist and what do they do? Why can't they just pick up the phone and call? What's a telegram, and why did mom leave us home alone...

Or take the story of The Blue Cup. In the story, there's a girl named Svetlana, her mom, and her dad. And when mom got stuck chatting with a friend in the kitchen, dad and Svetlana got upset (mom had promised to go out with them). So, they stormed out of the house. Not exactly the kind of example I'd use to teach my kid about behavior. Then they met a boy who was being called a fascist. That's a pretty heavy word for a six-year-old, but it's something they should know, especially since they talk about war in kindergarten.

The stories are full of words we don't use in everyday conversation with kids - chapaevtsy, pioneer, collective farm, and loads more.

Gaidar's got a knack for writing these laid-back stories that touch on Soviet life. Like how kids were left alone, or how people couldn't express their love and pride for their kids directly (I saw that as an adult in the story Smoke in the Forest, how the mom reacted to her son at the end).

Illustrations are few and far between, but the ones that are there are beautiful, calm, and not too flashy, emotional.

I think this book is more suited for older kids, maybe around 8 or 9 years old, so they can understand not just the kids' behavior, but also the adults' behavior. You'd need a grown-up nearby to explain the old words in a way that makes sense. It's a classic piece of children's literature, but it might be a bit tough for modern kids to get through. Still, the stories are calm, focus on family values, and have a historical context. I'd definitely recommend it.

I was really impressed with the build quality on this thing - I used it non-stop for a week and only had to charge it once. The value for money is definitely there, especially considering how long the battery life lasts.

live_helpFeatured FAQ

Is the book suitable for modern kids?

While the book is a classic, it may be too old-fashioned for some modern kids who are used to more modern stories and illustrations. However, if your child enjoys classic literature and is looking for a new challenge, this book might be a great fit.

How do I remove the permanent marker stain?

Unfortunately, I haven't been able to remove the stain with regular cleaning products yet. You might want to try using a specialized stain remover or consulting with a professional cleaner.

What's the price of the book?

The book costs 350 rubles, which is a reasonable price considering the quality of the book.

Who is the author?

The book features stories by Arkady Gaidar, a classic author of children's literature.

What's the design like?

The design is calm and kid-friendly, making it perfect for reading aloud to little ones.

Are the illustrations nice?

Yes, the illustrations by a real artist are warm and cozy, and they really bring the stories to life.

Is the book a good value for money?

Considering the quality of the book and the price of 350 rubles, I think it's worth considering if your child enjoys classic literature.

Can I return the book if I'm not satisfied?

Unfortunately, I'm not sure if Fix Price has a return policy for books. You might want to check with the store directly to see if they offer any returns or exchanges.

check_circlePros

•The hardcover is nice and sturdy, with a beautiful design that's perfect for kids.
•The illustrations by a real artist are warm and cozy, and they really bring the stories to life.
•The book includes several stories that are great for kids, and they're all classics.
•The price of 350 rubles is reasonable, especially considering the quality of the book.
•The book is a great way to introduce kids to classic literature and help them develop a love for reading.
•The design is calm and kid-friendly, making it perfect for reading aloud to little ones.

cancelCons

•The sales team wrote on the cover with a permanent marker, which is a major downside.
•I haven't been able to remove the permanent marker stain with regular cleaning products yet.
•The book may be too old-fashioned for some modern kids, who might find it boring.
•The stories may be too long or complicated for younger kids, who might get lost in the plot.
•The book doesn't have any modern features or illustrations that kids might find exciting.
•The cover is not waterproof, so it's not suitable for kids who like to get messy.