photo_library14
visibility5
Ürünstar 3.0
Hands Off by Masha Traub
Get ready to dive into the world of 'Hands Off', a thought-provoking novel by Masha Traub that delves into the complexities of human relationships and the importance of setting boundaries. This book will make you think twice about how you interact with others and the value of saying 'no'. It's a game-changer for anyone who's ever struggled to set healthy limits or deal with toxic relationships.
chevron_right
A Disappointing Read: My Thoughts on 'Hands Off'
summarizeEditor's Summary
I recently picked up 'Hands Off' by Masha Traub, expecting another great read from this author. Unfortunately, this one didn't quite live up to my expectations. The story takes place in a Moscow museum, where a team of quirky employees navigate their personal and professional lives amidst chaos. While I appreciated the unique premise, the execution fell short. With too much repetition and not enough depth, I found myself losing interest halfway through. If you're a fan of character-driven stories, you might enjoy this book, but for me, it was a total letdown. I was hoping for more nuanced character development and a more engaging plot, but what I got was a meandering story with too many convenient plot twists. The author's writing is engaging, and I did find myself turning the pages to see what would happen next, but overall, the book just didn't deliver.
settingsSpecifications
KararKötü
Atmosfer8/10
DilVeÜslup6/10
OkumaSüreci4/10
HikayeKalitesi4/10
KarakterGelişimi3/10
A Disappointing Read: My Thoughts on 'Hands Off'
Hello everyone!
I recently picked up the book 'Hands Off' by Masha Traub through my local library. I've been a fan of her work, but this one didn't quite live up to my expectations.
My copy is a 2012 edition, and I have to say, I was intrigued by the premise of the story. It's set in one of Moscow's museums, where a team of employees try to navigate their personal and professional lives amidst a chaotic work environment.
The team consists of Berta Abramovna Depressia, the main curator, an elderly woman who's always on TV; Leyla Makhmudovna, the main tour guide, another elderly woman who's a widow; Yelena Anatolyevna, a young woman who's struggling to cope with her partner's departure; Irina Markovna, a married woman with kids who's always coming up with new cleaning solutions; Snezhana Petrovna, a scientist studying music; Gulia, the janitor, a stubborn and rough woman; and Boris, the only man in the team, the representative of the technical services.
The story takes a strange turn when the museum director isn't on site, and the team starts to experience all sorts of bizarre occurrences - a mirror that's supposed to 'hex' anyone who looks into it, an allegedly higher-than-normal radiation level, and a team of unhappy women slowly losing their grip on reality.
I have to say, I was left trying to make sense of all this chaos with the help of a police officer, Mikhail Ivanovich Mozgovoy, who shows up at the museum, then keeps coming back for more, as the problems just keep piling up like a snowball.
What specifically didn't sit well with me about this book was the way the characters felt like they were overacting. It's like they were being way too loud and talkative, making it hard to read. I found myself getting tired of the main characters' constant chatter. Elena, on the other hand, was a bit too passive and lacked depth in her thoughts and emotions.
I struggled to get through this book, to be honest. I've read other books by Masha Traub that I devoured quickly, but this one was a real slog. I didn't want to put it down, but at the same time, I didn't want to keep reading it either. It was just so... drawn out.
I was frustrated to see the museum portrayed as this dirty, neglected place, where the staff are all weird and dysfunctional. The only redeeming quality was the story of Snezhana Petrovna and her work on the cantata, which was actually really interesting to read.
The whole story felt like a 'everything was terrible' narrative, and then suddenly, everyone finds their happiness and purpose. It felt a bit too convenient and unrealistic.
I loved the atmosphere in this book - it's like stepping back into the 90s, when museums were slowly recovering from the crisis but hadn't yet become the vibrant, engaging places they are today. In the book, the museum is portrayed as a weird, uninteresting place, and its staff as typical 'gray mice' or eccentric ladies. Now, museums are perceived differently, and in modern context, the book feels a bit dated, but it's still part of the author's bibliography. The atmosphere in the book reminded me of Russian TV series from the 2000s - I didn't watch many of those, but the images were familiar to me.
When it comes to the book's strengths, the easy writing style and the ability to read it 'between tasks' are definite pluses. However, for me, these advantages weren't enough to outweigh the other drawbacks. At times, I felt like the story was written by different people, with varying depth and style.
I won't discourage anyone from reading this story, as it might appeal to some people. However, I couldn't give it a high rating.
Overall, I was disappointed by 'Hands Off', but I'm glad I gave it a try. It's not a bad book, but it's not a great one either. If you're a fan of Masha Traub's work, you might enjoy this one, but if you're new to her writing, you might want to start with something else.
Rating: 2.5/5 stars
live_helpFeatured FAQ
Is 'Hands Off' a good book for fans of character-driven stories?
Yes, the book features a diverse cast of characters, each with their own quirks and flaws. While the story doesn't always live up to its potential, the characters are well-developed and relatable.
What's the book's setting, and how is it described?
The story takes place in a Moscow museum, and the author vividly describes the setting, making it easy to visualize the story.
Does the book tackle any heavy themes?
Yes, the author tackles themes like depression and relationships in a thoughtful way, but could have done so with more subtlety.
Is the book easy to read?
Yes, the writing is engaging, and the book is an easy read, making it perfect for a quick weekend getaway.
What's the book's message, and did it resonate with you?
The book's message is unclear, and I left feeling unsatisfied. While the author tackles some heavy themes, the execution falls short.
Would you recommend 'Hands Off' to fans of Masha Traub's other work?
Unfortunately, this book didn't live up to my expectations. While the author's unique take on museum life is intriguing, the execution falls short. Fans of Masha Traub's other work might enjoy this book, but for me, it was a total letdown.
What's the book's genre, and who is it suitable for?
The book is a work of literary fiction, and it's suitable for fans of character-driven stories and those interested in exploring the human condition.
Can you summarize the book's plot without giving away too many spoilers?
The story takes place in a Moscow museum, where a team of quirky employees navigate their personal and professional lives amidst chaos. While the premise is unique, the execution falls short, and the story meanders without a clear direction.
What did you expect from the book, and how did it differ from your expectations?
I expected a nuanced character-driven story with a more engaging plot, but what I got was a meandering story with too many convenient plot twists.
check_circlePros
- •The author's unique take on museum life is intriguing, and I appreciated the diversity of the characters.
- •The writing is engaging, and I found myself turning the pages to see what would happen next.
- •The characters' quirks and flaws make them relatable and endearing.
- •The setting of the Moscow museum is vividly described, making it easy to visualize the story.
- •The author tackles some heavy themes, like depression and relationships, in a thoughtful way.
- •The book is an easy read, and I devoured it in a few days.
- •The characters are well-developed and relatable, even if the story doesn"t always live up to its potential.
- •The author"s use of language is engaging and immersive, making it easy to get lost in the story.
cancelCons
- •The story is overly reliant on coincidence and convenient plot twists.
- •The characters' motivations and actions often feel forced or contrived.
- •The pacing is slow, and the story meanders without a clear direction.
- •The themes are heavy-handed, and the author doesn't subtlety enough.
- •The supporting characters feel underdeveloped and one-dimensional.
- •The book's message is unclear, and I left feeling unsatisfied.
- •The plot twists are predictable and lack surprise.
- •The character development is lacking, and I didn"t feel like I got to know the characters beyond their surface-level quirks.
